The Fake Master Drawings Hiding in Plain Sight
Amanda Miller ·
Listen to this article~3 min
Turns out, some supposed original drawings in a Munich collection are actually high-quality 19th-century reproductions. Here's how they fooled everyone.
You'd think a drawing in a museum collection is the real deal, right? Well, hold on. A recent investigation has revealed that some supposed original drawings in the Staatliche Graphische Sammlung München (SGSM) are actually high-quality reproductions. These replicas have been circulating in the art market and museum collections for years, fooling even experts.
The author, the curator of Netherlandish Art at the SGSM, dug into the origins of these repetitions. What they found is a fascinating story that goes back to the early nineteenth century. It turns out that the SGSM has a long history of reproducing artworks, which started as a way to share their collection with the world.
But here's the twist: the supposed replicas are not just any copies. They are polychrome collotypes – a type of photomechanical print that doesn't use halftone screens. These were produced with such exceptional quality that they can easily be mistaken for originals. They came from a portfolio of master drawings published between 1884 and 1900 by Wilhelm Schmidt, the director of the SGSM at the time.
### How Did These Collotypes Fool Everyone?
Collotypes are a fascinating technology. They were developed in the 19th century and allowed for very fine reproduction of images. Unlike halftone prints, which use dots to create shading, collotypes use a gelatine layer to hold ink, resulting in smooth, continuous tones. This made them ideal for reproducing drawings and other artworks with high fidelity.
Schmidt's portfolio was a big deal back then. It allowed people to own high-quality reproductions of master drawings from the SGSM. But over time, these prints lost their context. They were separated from their portfolios, framed, and eventually ended up in collections where they were mistaken for original drawings. And because they are so well-made, even connoisseurs have been fooled.
> "The supposed replicas are revealed to be exceptionally high-quality polychrome collotypes derived from a portfolio of master drawings from the SGSM published between 1884 and 1900."
### What This Means for Collectors and Curators
This discovery is a wake-up call for the art world. It shows that even the most experienced eyes can be deceived by a clever reproduction. For collectors, it's a reminder to always do your homework. For curators, it's a call to re-examine works in their collections that might have questionable provenance.
But it's not all bad news. These collotypes are actually important historical artifacts in their own right. They represent a milestone in the history of reproduction and are a testament to the skill of 19th-century printers. So rather than dismissing them as fakes, we should appreciate them for what they are: remarkable pieces of art history.
### The Takeaway
The next time you see a drawing that seems too good to be true, it just might be. But that doesn't mean it's not valuable. It's just a different kind of treasure. And for those of us who love art, that's a lesson worth learning.